A

Ask the Record

asktherecord.com

Doc 0000146127

CIA

This document describes an experiment involving twenty-four subjects in four groups who engaged in conversations with seventeen "experimenters" to study conversational control, noting that the results were consistent and showed no significant change in opinion expression as a function of reinforcement.

This is one record. The archive holds the rest — ask it anything across the MKUltra files and every answer is cited to the page.

Ask the archive about this →
/ .- -/ ·' ....... • .~·"" , # ·'~·. 1~ •••, .~ ... -.;.;· ..... ... : . / .. F'RO~t .· SUBJEC1' t .· . ~-· : : ... l. · In .._., cx;~-:lrir.cnt on jnflucncing convcrsatic:~al ccnti!!'.l~ticn, tt;cnty four s·..r.b jccts, chi.t!~d into fom· c:rol:.ps, cnrr:i.~d on ccnvcrsc.ticr.s too Tli. th scvcnt!!cn Cj=!:'arbenters. This reduced si tuo.tion, <J.rcad;:t numerically small in a st~tistical sense, to ~~ almo~t person to Jerson rclat5.o::.ship. '!hoe eztcns5.ve <:rr,cwlt of incivic.!::~l int<;rprctt!tic:n possible in such a si tua t.i on rcc!u::es the ·s cienti!ic i!S,t•~c t to tll!r.os t zero. · I 2." }.s 1J-,c~ic~..-t.~d :in trr,_.,~:.~itt:ll m-::;:•o !'ro:n author, r.n ::i.J:!?liccltic•n for "brc:d.r.·.··~shin;"11 1:1i.ght be found i.'1 such !!n e:-=ccri:.:mat as this. In its prE;r.sr~t fer;;:-this r:;p:-.r-t, of c:<p·Z!l'it:-::nt · offP.rs lHtle to si th-zr 1*bra.irt:i::~.:;hing11 or int-=:·rc~·~ti~·!"l t·:!chr.iq,~:~!;. 'Il1is lac~: is b!!;;t r.:r.ni::'e$~1){! by the c.uthor 1s r<:>cv~;:'li tic.·:~ i..!H:..t. the rc~lnt.ic:~ship effect bet·,·:·~~n th~ cxperir.~entcr (ink::-rce<'.tc. .~ ) c.:;d_ subject (interror.~~o) ·.ras r.ot r.:D~r.ar.:C.. The au.thc:r- t~se)f p::-,s:::s co;.r c~J.esticn c-.s to wl!~thcr or not v~rbn.l bch~vior -.-:ou.lci or co:.tlri b!l reinforc~d by ar;:-ccr.:ent :i.n a sit "..lnt.ie:a v.hcrein the subject (jr.t£;-rog(:e-prisc!ic:c). ciisliked the c;;:arir.:entcr- (interro;:,;ator - captc.•r) • . ._ . 3. Despite the indi·ddualistic l:tSse;:;e!:.ent affc-rc!ac! by scvent.~:~n exporiccnter:.; int-r::r·vie~"i.•·1t; t\:C~1ty feu: su!Jjccts, t1:\; rcsuJ.ts cbt.:~i.r:.;.d &'e })r~ct:tc:Ul:r ~~i\~or:;;::.ll:,r CC'!1stc~t, c:.r:d are as ,-.·ou.ld r.:cr-a:all~t.be C>.."PCC'Iiecl, viz: e.) the rat-~ c!' opinion:; c:-:pre:t:cd shoi'icd no si,:ni.fica.>1t c!lC~l!,;·~s r.s e. i"uncti(\:1 of :'(;~_ni"~rcc;r.cnt C.1!rj. .~ ~~ the opcrz.nt (L"liJ.:.:i.:-1 conu·olj pt:ricd.; b) Each of tho s·:.1'b~ic.ct.s f:ho·::.::d m incre~!:cd freq~.:~n~y of op:i.r.icn$ C'>':!?!"t1sscd d ui·:!.n~ ·the ar.rccr::~nt· .;.~ric.d; '• c) 'l'T~ont:y cr.c cf tw~nty four of the sub:i-::ct~ ·snor:~?d a d~cJ·E:.r~~cci f:'c::=C!~:e;r:::;y cf C';.)i:~ic:~s c:•:pr~::zod duri:-1£; thl~ cxt:i.nctic:1 (ci.S£[:rcr.:~on~.) pcdo~· • .... _ ··-·. ···-··· -·- ............... __ - ,. . . 'j ' • ··-I - I !J •• ~·· •· ;..." \. / / . " ./ t -~ •• 11. ''l'hczc result:; ,·;c,l1lc! ~(!e::1 th(::t tCJ offct· li ttlc pro~p·~ct for th·:!il· u t.ili::<: tic.:1 L:r u Co:a::.t:nl.:;t 11 c.>:pcdJ.If.:mt.·::l:" to Ll.CilJ.cvc :;t.:1y dc[;r.::o of ~uccc~~; in a 11iH'<(ilr;;:.:.:;b.ir,t;11 oi· 11i>ruinch<.:.ll~illt;11 nt.t.::Ji;pt cxc(;p t in t:1c ver-y il::; ...: ;:diat.c ini ti<Ll st.:l~C. · I S. 'l'hc a?p:Uc::.tion in this. j.n:i.tial st~;:;c l'roi.u.d be the situation lThcrcin the su:.j:::ct (pri!>or.er) is cnccura[,cc.i by the CXJ·~·r·ir.:cnter {ca,i'ltor) to c:-:prt'ls.s hi::: OiJinion~ as to 1what 1.h:} war The image displays a digitally rendered graphic featuring a vault door on the left and text on the right. The vault door is large and metallic, with numerous circular mechanisms and locking components. The text is centered and contains the title "THE BLACK VAULT" in large, stylized font. Below the title, smaller white text explains that the document was obtained from The Black Vault, an online database of declassified government documents, specifically referencing the MKULTRA/Mind Control Collection. A yellow hyperlink to "http://mkultra.theblackvault.com" is also visible. There are no photographs, handwritten annotations, signatures, official stamps, forms, diagrams, tables, or redactions present in this image. ~uccc~~; in a 11iH'<(ilr;;:.:.:;b.ir,t;11 oi· 11i>ruinch<.:.ll~illt;11 nt.t.::Ji;pt cxc(;p t in t:1c ver-y il::; ...: ;:diat.c ini ti<Ll st.:l~C. · I S. 'l'hc a?p:Uc::.tion in this. j.n:i.tial st~;:;c l'roi.u.d be the situation lThcrcin the su:.j:::ct (pri!>or.er) is cnccura[,cc.i by the CXJ·~·r·ir.:cnter {ca,i'ltor) to c:-:prt'ls.s hi::: OiJinion~ as to 1what 1.h:} war is :>.:>out'; 1wh:r th-:! priso~wr joined t.h-c n-ilit<l!j' scrvlcc 1 ; etc. Hy the expcril::cnter 1 s . encourar;c!:;~nt th't'ough agret:rncnt, -th~ subject may £0 on t.nd on in his opinion e>:pre::sicr:. 'Dms th·:l subject 1~ir,ht af'forc! the cxpcrir.;cntor a psycholo!:ic.'ll profile of hir.1!:elf, anc.1 thus roigh t expose a p;;ycholob"icnl point of \"l.tJ..!i·~r.::.bili ty ,·;hich could be used as a ccp.:u·tur~ point or en.t i".f 'i"Cd[;e in the. CCp~rsondization Of "brzJ.l'!.Wa$hing11 • 6. Even this i."li t~.a1 ~??Hcatio:1 tc 1'brciw:ashint;11 c~mot be deduced .frc.:1 t.his r-:!)O::"t Of e:•:peri:r,':):lt, hcr::evcr, bocau!::C thn cfi'?Ct C"f a SJ.tuati0!1 of L'.nt~t;Cr:isn bet·,:;ecn e):p~rir.lenter E'.."ld Stlbject {Sec para~;i-::.p!1 2) has not been tteasur~d~ - .. '"; .... . ' ... I· ••• . ' ... ........... • . . :···~.·'; .. ~ ...... ;.~ .. ·.:·. ., ~:·-:~r:·::=;~~,.·\,;:=~~~ ' t .......... •. . . lh~•L. .. • ••~:~">· ;.;..,:..;..·.<<~:.·.":~~:;~ti r ... - The page is a scanned document with typewriter text and some handwritten annotations. A circled number "347" is present in the top right corner. The document is a memorandum with fields for "MEMORANDUM TO," "FROM," and "SUBJECT," all of which appear to be filled in with typewritten text, including names and titles. There are also several bulleted or numbered points that appear to be findings or observations from an experiment. Towards the bottom right, there is a handwritten signature or annotation above the number "12." There is no visual evidence of experimental procedures, equipment, facilities, or photographs. The page is primarily a text-heavy document with typed content. There are no photographs, diagrams, forms, or tables. Scattered across the page are multiple small, dark ink dots, which appear to be part of the printing or scanning process rather than intentional annotations. A handwritten number "-2-" is visible near the bottom center of the page. There are no visible official stamps, redactions, or any visual evidence directly related to experimental procedures or equipment.

Original source: view the released document

More from the MKUltra files